Combining Web and TV

by Philip Greenspun and Michael Schwarz

Television is good for reaching a broad audience. A PBS show is viewed by 2-6 million people; a commercial network show by 10-25 million. Television brings characters and stories to life in a way that is difficult to do in other media. You can humanize characters and lift them out of the realm of statistics. You can use drama to generate emotions and motivate people to action.

Television is terrible at distributing information. The script for a half-hour national network news broadcast would fit into a fraction of the front page of The New York Times. Less than one newspaper page. If you're trying to use TV to distribute information, you're in trouble.

Television is terrible at localization. Most TV is produced for national broadcast. It is extremely expensive to localize content and in general you can't expect to have the footage, much less the editing resources. Even if you had localized content, it isn't clear how you'd distribute it to stations since distribution networks are literally "broadcast" technology.

Enter the Web.

A Web service backed by a relational database can localize an enormous database and make it relevant to anyone willing to type in his or her zip code. Example: www.scorecard.org. A Web service can offer tremendous detail to readers who are willing to read and be engaged.

Given a TV broadcast that will herd millions of users to a Web site and a Web service that localizes data and involves those users, it is natural to think about giving those users an opportunity to collaborate and communicate with each other. For example, along with a show on juvenile crime, it is natural to offer a service that lets people manage volunteers for after-school programs in their neighborhood.

The Future

The future is what Corporation for Public Broadcasting calls "Enhanced Television". This is using the HDTV channel to convey a traditional TV program plus a large amount of supplemental data. Viewers will be able to start and stop programs. Programs will include markers at various points leading viewers to content embedded in the data stream. The most frequently requested supplemental data will come straight from the broadcast stream and drill-down information would come from the public Internet. Taking action will necessarily require some upstream communication if only so that the activities of multiple collaborating viewers can be coordinated via a server.

About the Authors

Michael Schwarz is the executive producer of In Search of Law and Order, a three-hour documentary on kids and violence. He is the president of Kikim Media and has been producing documentaries since 1978.

Philip Greenspun has been building Web services since 1993.


philg@mit.edu
and
mschwarz@kikim.com

Reader's Comments

I think the major technological constraint for this future of "video on demand" and "localization of the video media" is the mass availability of bandwidth. Just thought I would mention that.

-- Paul Konigsberg, February 23, 2000
Add a comment | Add a link