The helicopter checkride

Last Friday I took a checkride to add a Private helicopter rating to my Commercial pilot’s certificate.  The Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) will, in theory, examine applicants for this rating but in practice prefers that you pay a Designated Examiner.  The fun started at 9:00 am in Nashua, NH at CR Helicopters with Joe Brigham, a retired legend in the cranberry bogs of New England.  The oral portion of the exam lasted until nearly 11:00 am at which point the winds had picked up from calm to a typically unpleasant New England 10 knots gusting 15.  When the objective is to hold the helicopter steady within a foot or two of a reference point on the ground these kinds of winds make life tricky, especially in the Robinson R22, one of the world’s lightest helicopters.


Running the startup checklist on the R22 takes about 4 minutes during which one tests the engine’s dual independent ignition systems, the carb heat, the sprag clutch that enables the rotors to freewheel if the engine quits, and the low RPM warning horn that sounds if the blades begin to slow down.  The test complete, I called Nashua Tower to ask for clearance to a grassy area east of the paved 5500′-long runway.  Once we got across the runway Joe asked to see a sideways hover taxi then a backwards hover taxi.  These are done with the skids of the helicopter 3-5 feet off the ground.  I set the helicopter back on the grass and Joe asked me to pick it back up.  When we were 2′ from the ground he twisted the throttle on his side of the ship to idle, simulating an engine failure.  The helicopter immediately started a yaw to the left.  I pushed the right antitorque pedal to bring the nose back to where it had been pointed.  As the R22 settled towards the ground I pulled the collective pitch control to use some of the rotational energy of the blades to cushion the impact.  Every time you pull more collective the helicopter wants to yaw to the right so I had to step on the left pedal.  We thumped down on the ground about 1 second after Joe had closed the throttle, reasonably smoothly and within about 5 degrees of where we’d started on the heading.  The standard for a Private rating is 10 percent and Joe declared that I had demonstrated a hovering autorotation.


The next maneuver was the Quickstop, simulating an attempt to take off and then an abort due to failure to clear trees or the appearance of an obstacle.  We had to get over to the side of a small hill about 1000′ away.  I accelerated the helicopter to about 40 knots and 40′ above the ground and then pulled sharply back on the cyclic to flare off the speed while simultaneously lowering collective to prevent the helicopter from ballooning up in altitude and using the antitorque pedals to prevent yaw.  At the end of the Quickstop Joe asked for a running landing to simulate bringing the helicopter down at a high altitude in which the machine lacks sufficient power to hover.  We slid into the grass.


We were near the hill at this point so it was time to demonstrate slope operations.  One approaches the slope at a 45-degree angle with the helicopter yawed so that the skids are parallel to the slope at all times.  You hover so that the upslope skid is about 2-3′ above the ground and then gradually lower the ship until the upslope skid touches.  At that point you push the cyclic into the slope to lock the skid against the slope while simultaneously adjusting collective pitch to hold a level attitude.  After pausing in that position for a moment I lowered the collective to bring the downslope skid into contact with the ground while simultaneously adding addition cyclic towards the upslope to keep that skid locked.


Slope operations complete we started with a normal takeoff and normal approach.  Unless you are all by yourself in a Blackhawk you don’t take off straight up in a helicopter.  You bring the ship up into a hover and then push the cyclic forward until the helicopter is flying fast enough that the blades are biting into fresh undisturbed air.  This is called “Effective Translational Lift” (ETL) and the helicopter rapidly picks up speed and then altitude beyond this point.  The normal approach and landing is a reasonably shallow angle coming down toward some traffic cones abeam the Nashua windsock.  Once back on the ground Joe asked for a maximum performance takeoff in which one does try to depart as nearly vertical as is possible.  This involves spending some time under the R22’s “deadman’s curve”, a combination of having a low airspeed and a low altitude such that it would be impossible to make a smooth landing in the event of an engine failure.  Joe asked for a steep approach to the cones.  This is not straight down as you might think but rather just steep enough that you could clear the trees around a mid-size field before landing on someone’s helipad.


Next up was an autorotation.  This involves closing the throttle about 700′ above the ground and gliding down at about 65 knots and 1500′-per-minute descent rate.  Starting roughly 40′ above the ground I began to pull back on the cyclic to slow our forward speed and reduce the descent rate.  When the forward speed was just about gone I leveled the ship with the cyclic so that the tail did not strike the ground and began to let the R22 sink towards the ground with just a bit of forward speed.  At the last minute I pulled the collective to cushion the final impact with energy from the rotating blades.


The final part of the checkride was escaping from a vortex ring state.  Joe took the controls and slowed the helicopter down so that we had lost almost all forward speed.  Then he lowered the collective to start a 500 foot-per-minute descent from our 700′ altitude.  The helicopter began “settling with power” into its own disturbed air, falling suddenly much faster than the initial descent rate established by Joe.  The controls became mushy just as he said “You have the controls”.  The way to escape from a vortex ring state is by pushing the cyclic forward to try to fly the helicopter forward out of the disturbed air while simultaneously lowering the collective so that the helicopter isn’t beating the air so hard.  Once I had recovered some flying speed I pulled on the collective to resume a climb.


That was it.  What can one do with a Private helicopter rating?  Take friends for rides, basically, and that’s about it.  I’ll be starting work on my Commercial rating next week.

9 thoughts on “The helicopter checkride

  1. Congratulations Philip!

    Are you planning on leasing helicopter time, pooling money into a coop to purchase one or buying your own?

  2. Gary: I don’t want to do a huge amount of flying until I’ve built up my skills more. Ergo most of my helicopter flying for the next 6 months will be lessons toward my Commercial rating. Lessons need to be booked with an instructor at a flight school, where they always have helicopters for rent. So it will be just as easy to rent until I’ve gotten my Commercial. After that an insurance company might not be too terrified to write me a policy on an R44, the 4-seat Robinson that will give me more stability, more time to react to an engine failure (more inertia in rotor system so the blades don’t spin down as fast), fuel injection so that carb icing isn’t an issue, a back seat for the dog, etc.

    Unless I knew a lot of super rich people with enormous country estates I’m not sure that I’d have an actual use for an R44. Average citizens in the U.S. are basically restricted to taking off and landing at airports, in which case you might as well just use an airplane. An airplane the same price as the R44 would go a lot faster, be capable of flight through instrument meteorological conditions, would carry more people and bags, and would get better gas mileage.

    The R44 would be fun, though, and I’ll probably try to get one in partnership with one other pilot here in Boston. The insurance is almost $40,000 per year so it will be good to have someone with whom to split it.

  3. Philip: Ever consider becoming a radio traffic reporter? Or maybe one of those OJ Bronco chasing news guys?

  4. This definitely sounds like something where I’d end up telling myself, “well gee, it is true that I passed the FAA certification test, but I don’t even feel slightly confident to be flying this thing around by myself.”

    I did a very crude run at some safety numbers and it looked like non-military helicopter flight was only around 25% more dangerous (in terms of engine hours) than general aviation (which I read to be non-commercial jet flying). Is this true? Because every description I’ve ever read about flying a helicopter sounds much, much more than 25% more complicated and 25% less safe than a plane.

  5. Mandrake: One problem with having a job is that you have to go to work every day. In aviation this becomes life-threatening because going to work every day means flying in whatever weather God chooses to dish out. If celebrity criminals would agree to flee only on days with at least a 3000′ ceiling and surface winds less than 10 knots I would feel a lot better. One commercial helicopter operation that I would be happy to work is sightseeing. Aerial tourists don’t come knocking if it is raining outside. One thing that would be fun is to drag an R44 around the U.S. for a long summer. Park in a different scenic tourist-dense location for a month at a time and hang out a barnstorming shingle. Move on to the next state when it stops being fun. Alaska is also a reasonable place to operate any kind of small aircraft business for a short season. There are a lot of places that tourists want to go that are only accessible in a floatplane or helicopter. Not to mention the fact that it is incredibly scenic.

  6. Oh boy…when is the contest to give away a fun Helicopter ride to your favorite Blog reader?

  7. Michael: Regarding the safety stats… the civilian helicopter fleet is pretty safe (nearly as safe as general aviation airplanes as you point out) but the overwhelming number of hours are flown by professional pilots. Flight training is also quite safe. However, supposedly the stats on privately owned privately flown helicopters are as much as 10X worse than the professionally flown helis. I don’t feel scared flying the R22 by myself right now but I would not fly by myself if I had not flown for, say, 6 weeks. Whereas my simple fixed wing airplane feels a little bit alien after a long trip abroad but probably not unsafe.

Comments are closed.