The charms of the installation art exhibits in Marfa, Texas are often lost on Americans but the place is very popular with German tourists. My favorite new experience in Marfa was a dark room filled with blue LEDs hung from wires (photo doesn’t really do it justice due to massive overexposure compared to the darkness you feel with just your eyes) by Erwin Redl. Shortly before our little group was enjoying the high desert scenery and trying to understand the art, the Associated Press reported that “In a scene reminiscent of Somalia, frenzied [Iraqi] crowds dragged the burned, mutilated bodies of four American contractors through the streets of a town west of Baghdad on Wednesday and strung two of them up from a bridge” (source).
A German couple talked about how they’d met some retired U.S. Air Force pilots in California. “They were lied to,” the wife noted. “They were just 19-year-olds and nobody told them they would be bombing civilians. Otherwise they would never have bombed German cities.” The implication was that bombing civilians was so clearly immoral that nobody would do it knowingly. Certainly the results of the bombing were terribly painful for Germans:
“The total bomb tonnage for the Second World War dropped by both the RAF and the 8th and 15th Air Forces in Europe on Germany totalled 1,234,767 tons of bombs more than 60 percent of which were dropped between July 1944 and April 1945. The Allied aerial onslaught killed no fewer than 305,000 German factory workers or area residents in targeted cities. It wounded about 780,000 other persons, made 1,865,000 people refugees, compelled the removal of another 4,885,000 additional persons, and cut off 20,000,000 people from their public utilities. By the third quarter of l944, coping with the aftermath of the Allied air strikes tied down an estimated four and one-half million workers, about 20 percent of the non-farm labor force, in cleaning and rebuilding operations.” (source)
Equally certain is the fact that for every German civilian killed or inconvenienced by bombing there was a statistical chance that an Allied soldier’s life would be spared. The German death camp system for Jews was also impaired in efficiency and brought to an earlier end by the Allied bombing of German civilians. Apparently there is a large school of thought within Germany at least that saving the lives of Allied solders and Jews did not justify killing German civilians randomly in hopes of striking those who were useful to the war effort and/or death camp system.
1940s summary: We were at war with the German and Japanese governments and we killed many civilians who did not support those governments and with whom we had no quarrel.
What about today? I have not been following events in Iraq very closely but I seem to recall American officials saying that it is tough to prevail against our enemies there because we can’t find them. They hide amongst the general population and only come out at night in small bands. Yet last week in Fallujah a huge group of people who apparently hate Americans and are prone to expressing that hatred violently exposed themselves in broad daylight, right in the open. What better opportunity for rolling out the helicopter gunships? Apparently the military commanders in Iraq did not think so because they didn’t bother to attack any of the rioters.
Modern summary: We are at war with subsets of the civilian population in various countries around the world but we are only willing to attack governments. It is tough to see a path to victory via this strategy because we’re actually at peace with the governments of France, Germany, et al., and in many cases close personal friends with the owners of countries such as Saudi Arabia, Yemen, et al. We can only occasionally find a government or country owner that we don’t like, e.g., the Taliban in Afghanistan or Saddam in Iraq. Our military is able to dispose of said government or dictator very quickly but with victory we become the new government in that corner of the world. And then we discover that it was not the former dictator trying to kill us but rather a subset of the civilians in that country.
Full post, including comments