Crash of 1987 compared to today
The news today was unsettling. Two of the nation’s largest investment banks, Merrill Lynch and Lehman, are to disappear, along with thousands of high paying jobs. AIG, one of the world’s largest insurance companies, is also on the verge of bankruptcy. All of this seems to have been caused by improper valuation of mortgage-backed securities. The brightest minds on Wall Street sincerely believed, apparently, that an old wooden house in Cleveland was worth $350,000 and that a guy whose job skills were limited to collecting welfare was going to start making big payments on that house just as soon as his one year payment-free grace period elapsed.
Could it be that we need smarter folks working on Wall Street? Let’s compare to 1987.
On Black Monday, October 19, 1987, the Dow Jones Industrial Average fell 22.6%. What were the consequences of this collapse? By today’s standards, there weren’t any. The stock market fell. The same investment banks and funds that had been operating on Wall Street continued to operate. Real estate, which had become a bit of a bubble, especially in condos, started to slide about a year later. Home prices in the Boston area did not return to their 1987 peaks until perhaps 1996, i.e., 9 years later. But by and large people kept their jobs and companies continued to function.
Back in the 1980s the smartest graduates of M.I.T. went to work in engineering and science. In our present decade, the brightest young minds with technical degrees are drawn to Wall Street where they develop elaborate can’t fail schemes to outperform the market. Apparently there were some risks that the bright quants failed to evaluate properly and now their employers are bankrupt.
Perhaps the answer is that we need fewer smart people on Wall Street.
Full post, including comments