Windows Vista First Impressions
I bought a Toshiba 13″ laptop at BestBuy yesterday for $750, just to have a lightweight laptop with included DVD drive to take to Africa. The machine has more or less everything once should need: 1 GB of RAM, 160 GB hard drive, DVD burner, Webcam, FireWire and USB ports, etc. It also came with Windows Vista preinstalled.
I tried doing some basic things with Vista, such as changing the workground from “WORKGROUP” to “MSHOME”. This involved trips into the Help system and finding help descriptions that didn’t match up to the dialog boxes. It was possible from some of the network dialog boxes to pick a collection of checkboxes that would, when Apply was clicked, result in a 1960s mainframe-style error of “incompatible parameters”.
Vista can’t connect to my Infrant NAS disk array, even after I upgraded the firmware on the Infrant. The XP machines have no trouble with this. The worst thing about Vista is that it doesn’t like to say no. When connecting to a network server that it has discovered, it puts up a “working” thermometer and will keep incrementing it for about five minutes. It never does work, but Vista never seems to give up. Dead Windows File Explorer programs litter the desktop and need to be killed with the red X in the upper right.
During a lot of system administration tasks, bizarre dialog boxes pop up demanding extra administrator rights, even though the machine only has one user, which was configured without a password.
The system tends to be sluggish, even with 1 GB of RAM and a modern dual-core CPU. Although Vista is supposed to be virus-proof, the system shipped with McAfee firewall and virus protection software (which I uninstalled, along with everything else that seemed superfluous, in an attempt to boost the machine’s responsiveness).
Summary: So far inferior in every way to Windows XP.
[Update: I copied a bunch of Canon RAW files from an EOS 5D, which has been out for two years, onto the Vista machine. Unlike my patched XP machine, which has a Microsoft extension to be able to show thumbnails from RAW photos, the Vista machine treats these as an unknown file type and cannot show thumbnails in the Windows Explorer. Yet another disappointment…]
Full post, including comments