Bono, U2, and the rest of us voting our pocketbooks
The Sunday New York Times business section carries an article about tax shelters in the Netherlands for people such as writers, artists, musicians, and other entities who get most of their income from royalties; in the aggregate, these folks are able to escape tax on approximately $1 trillion in annual income. With a little creative accounting and legal work, the effective tax rate can be reduced to 1.5 percent. Bono and U2, the billionaire advocates for greater aid by rich world governments to people in poor countries, have not had to worry about this until recently. Ireland has long exempted all income by musicians, writers, and artists. Bono was thus out there advocating the spending of tax revenues to which he himself had not contributed. Ireland is going to start taxing royalty income over $320,000 per person per year, which has led Bono and U2 to migrate their royalty-generating properties to the Netherlands. The article talks about how Bono is taking criticism as a hypocrite for advocating massive tax-funded relief schemes when he himself has never paid any taxes.
Is Bono unusual for voting his pocketbook?
I thought about the people I know who are relatively well-off. They are more or less evenly divided between Republican and Democrat, but the division is not random. Those who get their money every year as a salary tend to be Democrats. Those who start small businesses and get their money in big lumps as capital gains when they sell those businesses tend to support the Republicans. If you are a W2 employee with a high income, it turns out that it doesn’t cost you much to rail against Bush’s idiocy and the unfairness of heterosexual-only marriage. Proposed tax rates on ordinary income are very similar from the two parties. On the other hand, the Reagan capital gains tax cuts were dramatic, making it much more lucrative to start, grow, and eventually sell a company. A small business guy who says “I hate the Republicans” is saying “I am so enthusiastic about the teaching of Evolution in Kansas schools that I want to pay twice as much in taxes.”
Politicial scientists have found that the correlation between income and party affiliation isn’t all that strong, but they were looking at ordinary income where the tax policies of the parties aren’t very different. I wonder if people who made most of their money via capital gains disproportionately support the Republicans….
Full post, including comments