Have South and Central America become more conservative because the voters who wanted a massive welfare state all moved to the U.S.?

The idea of ever-larger-and-more-compassionate government seems to have fallen out of favor lately in Central and South America. Here’s a graphic attributing the shift to the dismantling of USAID (source):

What if the reason is the Biden-Harris administration’s open border policy? Suppose that everyone in Central and South America who wanted to live in a cradle-to-grave work-optional welfare state migrated to the U.S. in 2021-20244. The voters who are left behind are, therefore, the conservative ones.

Separately, how are people feeling about yesterday’s election in Brazil? If it didn’t take a few weeks to count the votes and include a last-minute reversal can it be considered in any way free or fair by California standards? Also, I thought that the U.S. was the only democracy in which an 80-year-old could win the demanding chief executive job but, per usual, was apparently wrong.

(It looks like Lula won using some of the same tactics that Democrats have used recently in the U.S. AP: “Legislation to reduce the country’s workweek from six days to five and weekly working hours from 44 to 40 without reducing pay was approved by Congress 10 days before the runoff. … In September, Lula announced a 15% increase in payments under Brazil’s main welfare program, Bolsa Família, which bases benefits on family size and the number of children. The increase took effect this week, days before the election, and will benefit nearly 50 million people. … Lula on Wednesday endorsed credit relief and tax incentives for small businesses, giving them access to low-interest government loans through public banks and allowing them to renegotiate some of their debt. … Lula also is sending to Congress a bill to establish zero-fare public transportation on weekends.” Question: How is Lula going to argue that Elon Musk will pay for it all? Also, maybe this could be a positive for the U.S.? Brazil right now has a much lower personal income tax rate than the U.S. does, about 27.5% vs. over 50% for Californians and successful New Yorkers. With all of the new state-administered transfers, Brazil might raise its top tax rates and, thus, become less of a competitive threat to the U.S. for certain kinds of enterprises. France is the only nation with a larger welfare state, as a percentage of GDP, than the U.S. and they’re not much of a competitor.)

Related to the human export angle, “Caracas Is Eerily Safe. State Death Squads Made Sure of It.” (New York Times) mostly attributes improved safety in Venezuela to Delcy Rodríguez and Nicolás Maduro killing suspected criminals, but the open borders may also have been critical:

It’s undeniable that security has improved in Caracas and much of the rest of the country, but criminologists expressed skepticism over that figure, which would give Venezuela one of the lowest murder rates in the Americas.

Mass migration also played a role, with gang members constituting a small percentage of the millions who fled Venezuela’s economic collapse.

And just where did Venezuela’s most criminally-adept citizens end up? The NYT doesn’t say, nor do they mention José Antonio Ibarra, the Venezuelan enricher who killed Laken Riley. U.S. taxpayers will be funding Mr. Ibarra’s room, board, health care, and security for approximately the next 60 years. Mr. Ibarra won’t be able to vote in any Venezuelan elections due to his residence-for-life here in the U.S. (source)

Loosely related, If the dark days don’t have you in a suicidal mood… (quoting a Michel Houellebecq novel):

Are you from Brittany?” he asked. “Yes—from Saint-Brieuc!” she replied happily. “But I really like Brazilian dance,” she added, obviously trying to absolve herself for her disinterest in African dance. Much more of this and Bruno would really get irritated. He was starting to get pissed off about the world’s stupid obsession with Brazil. What was so great about Brazil? As far as he knew, Brazil was a shithole full of morons obsessed with soccer and Formula One. It was the ne plus ultra of violence, corruption and misery. If ever a country were loathsome, that country, specifically, was Brazil. Sophie,” announced Bruno, “I could go on vacation to Brazil tomorrow. I’d look around a favela. The minibus would be armor-plated; so in the morning, safe, unafraid, I’d go sightseeing, check out eight-year-old murderers who dream of growing up to be gangsters; thirteen-year-old prostitutes dying of AIDS. I’d spend the afternoon at the beach surrounded by filthy-rich drug barons and pimps. I’m sure that in such a passionate, not to mention liberal, society I could shake off the malaise of Western civilization. You’re right, Sophie: I’ll go straight to a travel agent as soon as I get home.”

In the Department of Election Predictions, it is the 10th anniversary of this tweet:

23 thoughts on “Have South and Central America become more conservative because the voters who wanted a massive welfare state all moved to the U.S.?”

  1. Yes, Phil! Your thesis is entirely correct. I am indeed a far-right-wing conservative and that is what the good people of Brazil voted for. Watch as the remainder of the Americas follow the trailblazing winners in Brazil.

    • Congratulations, Mr. Silva! But your victory may not be inconsistent with the drift-via-migration-of-welfare-enthusiasts. Brazilians haven’t benefited from truly enlightened U.S. enrichment welcome policies, such as Temporary Protected Status. Possibly as a consequence, a smaller percentage of Brazilians live in the U.S. vs. the countries where politicians characterized as “right-wing” have won.

    • Obrigado, Phil! Having read your blog for years, I know that you are a Proud and Loud Citizen of Portugal, so we both speak the same language in so many ways. How are the “students” behaving in your new country of Portugal?

      And, you note that “Brazilians haven’t benefited from truly enlightened U.S. enrichment welcome policies.” Of course they haven’t! Why would they leave a country where my policies have resulted in GDP per capita ranking 85th globally vs. only 10th in the U.S.? And, even bigger numbers are on the way. Can we get to 95th? I think so!

    • “Among all countries tabulated, Palestine produced the starkest imbalance: 93.09% of valid ballots (1,078 votes) went to Lula, with Flávio receiving just 3.97% (46 votes) — the incumbent’s single highest country-level percentage worldwide. The result reflects solidarity and humanitarian worker communities with strong ties to left-leaning Brazilian civil society organizations.” is an interesting excerpt. There are more than 1,000 Brazilians being paid to ladle out free food, health care, education, etc. to Arabs calling themselves “Palestinian”? How is that possible? More than half of adults in the West Bank aren’t in the labor force. Almost 30% of those who are in the labor force are unemployed. Why wouldn’t the virtuous NGOs (“non-governmental” except that they can survive only with government (taxpayer) funding) hire locals? What specialized skills do Brazilians have that aren’t found among Arabs?

    • Perhaps the Brazilians in Gaza have a “specialized skill” that is shared with the majority of their native population, as demonstrated yesterday: stupidity.

  2. hi phil, even though you are a paleocon I do believe you will really enjoy the Brazilian presidential debate between Bolsonaro Jr. and Lula. Seeing Lula’s incredible performance in that debate no wonder he won the election.

    They do it a lot better in Brazil, no fake mods looking for their moment in the spotlight by dunking on the candidates. Just two candidates going at it, talking to each other and the camera directly:

    https://youtu.be/RugVB17uRVM

    What is interesting is that under Bolsonaro pere, the government vastly relaxed ammunition sales. These sales were found to have later gone to drug lords and paramilitary groups operating across Brazil, convicted criminals had been left on the registration lists and got to buy ammunition directly.

    • Lula was talking so fast in that debate that the interpreter couldn’t keep up. Bolsonaro Jr. was talking at half the speed? The young man asks voters to do “math”? That seems like a bad strategy! He also criticizes Lula for deficit spending (10% of GDP right now!). Lula, by contrast, talked about all the great free stuff that the government would give to people, e.g., more paid time off for maternity leave.

    • > For all his opposition to immigration and paleoconservatism he married a Chinese […]

      I have read a few of his books, the impression I get is that he is pissed off with everyone in equal measure, immigrants, non-immigrants, natives, etc. For all the anti-immigrant rhetoric, one can find rhetoric that implies that the West is dying (by not procreating) because of excessive hedonism in his books.

      The title of the following book describes his political stance better: “H. P. Lovecraft: Against the World, Against Life”

  3. One thing is certain, though I can’t quite explain it: why are today’s voters increasingly choosing older candidates to lead their countries?

    • I’d never seen Lula speak. After following the above debate link, I’m kind of amazed that he is 80. Age has been a lot kinder to him than it has been to our greatest president ever (Joe Biden).

  4. What specialized skills do Brazilians have that Arabs lack? My guess is Brazilians have a lower theft rate than locals.. Guest workers wouldn’t have extended families wanting to loot the aid organizations.

    • I asked ChatGPT: “In October 2023, Brazil’s Ministry of Foreign Affairs reported approximately 6,000 Brazilian citizens living in the Palestinian territories, almost all in the West Bank. CNN Brasil subsequently reported that most were dual nationals and permanent residents.”

      It says that basically these are Arabs calling themselves “Palestinians” who for whatever reason have Brazilian passports. So we’re informed that life under Israeli occupation is intolerable and also that roughly 6,000 people who could live in Brazil choose instead to live under Israeli occupation. When given the choice between living in freedom and living under “apartheid”, people choose apartheid.

  5. Phil, thank you for this post! Vucic in Serbia, another right-wing candidate, also lost recently in the news. These are stark indicators for the midterms here in the U.S., which are only next week!!! Are you excited?

    • samue: I wouldn’t say that I’m excited about the upcoming elections because I know that there aren’t any U.S. politicians who share my political beliefs, e.g., that people should have to work for 8 years (W-2 or 1099) before voting, returning the U.S. to how it worked in the 19th century (men began working at 13 and voting at 21; nobody was on federal welfare and only a tiny percentage of voters were in protracted education). Even if the Jew-hating transferists, such as Abdulrahman Mohamed El-Sayed, don’t win, I won’t be too excited because I assume that someone similar will win soon enough. The “someone else will pay for it all” and “the Jews are to blame” messages are too powerful not to succeed with the transformed-by-immigration American electorate.

  6. WSJ: “The Brazilian real slid nearly 8% on Monday, its greatest one-day decline since 1999, according to LSEG data. The country’s benchmark stock index fell 14%, the worst one-day drop since the onset of the Covid-19 pandemic. The index’s plunge triggered a circuit breaker, leading Brazil’s stock-exchange operator to temporarily halt trading.” — https://www.wsj.com/finance/brazils-surprise-election-outcome-set-to-batter-stocks-real-35253aa8

    Where is Paul Krugman to say that the Brazilian market will never recover?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *