Inequality at an institution that officially hates inequality (Harvard)

From 2025, Harvard’s latest win in court and the New York Times:

I personally don’t understand why Harvard, which officially says that inequality is “one of America’s most vexing problems”, is willing to accept any federal money. Harvard is a rich institution in a richer-than-average state. One would think that they’d seek money from the Massachusetts state government and ask that all federal money be redirected to less-wealthy universities in poorer-than-average states, e.g., University of Michigan.

Some data recently published on X shows that, apparently, inequality begins at home:

Harvard pays a professor more than 6X what it pays one of the professors’ graduate student slaves, most of whom will likely never get a decent job in the pyramid scheme that is American academia (see also Nature Magazine). In Denmark, on the other hand, a professor earns only about 2X what a PhD student doing the actual labor earns. If Harvard hates inequality, which it says that it does, why not adopt a similar scale to what works in Denmark?

Note that the slaves went on strike last month. “Harvard grad students strike again, citing inadequate harassment protections” (Science Magazine):

For the second time this year, the Harvard Graduate Students Union has gone on strike after the university failed to provide a “meaningful response” to demands for better pay and stronger protections for survivors of harassment and noncitizen student workers. The first strike, which began on 21 April, lasted 40 days until the university agreed to begin new negotiations. But on 27 October, research assistants and teaching fellows walked away from their labs and classrooms once again following what the union said was a final unsuccessful bargaining session.

How could Harvard better protect victims so that nobody at Harvard would have to endure what survivor Kristin Knouse of Whitehead/MIT endured?

For a year and a half, the Harvard union, which represents 4000 students, has asked the university to establish third-party arbitration for harassment-related proceedings. It currently handles them internally, through the Title IX office, which administers the federal ban on sex discrimination in education. Unions at several other institutions, including the University of Michigan, MIT, and New York University, have negotiated such arrangements. But Harvard has refused, arguing that federal privacy laws prevent it from sharing Title IX information with third parties, the union says. … Among the standard-bearers on this issue is Claire Traweek, a graduate student in mechanical engineering who says she left her laboratory after experiencing harassment. As she has described in rallies over the past week, some of Traweek’s men colleagues made sexist comments, called women “birds,” and expressed preferences based on women’s physical attributes, among other offenses.

(Was one of Russell Brand’s cousins at Harvard? Wouldn’t it have to be someone from the Islamic Republic of England who would refer to a woman (a term that Harvard students, faculty, and administrators are generally unable to define) as a “bird”?)

2 thoughts on “Inequality at an institution that officially hates inequality (Harvard)”

  1. Phil, this is such a timely and topical post…thank you, as always!

    Inequality is something that you know, of course, is near and dear to me, and the Complicated and Deep Research I do every day as the Singular Greatest Scholar of Black Studies Plagiarism speaks to the commitment of both me and Harvard towards eliminating inequality. As such, my $1.5m annual salary (plus some wonderful “other” benefits!) is just a start in terms of Equality-izing the gross inequality that still exists between Great Scholars in Black Studies Plagiarism and those in other “disciplines” (can we even fairly call them “disciplines”?…you tell me!). More later…off to do some “banking” right now in Harvard Square!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *