New Year’s Resolution: toss out the Protestant work ethic?
Time to think about planning for 2016. Could this be the right time to quit your job?
In theory, the U.S. is a nation influenced by the Protestant work ethic, but in practice the percentage of Americans who choose to work is falling (chart). I’m listening to The Other Side of History: Daily Life in the Ancient World right now. The professor says that the idea that work was somehow ennobling or inherently rewarding would have been considered laughable in Ancient Greece.
As a suburban dog walker who mostly works from home, I tend to meet other suburbanites with dogs who are home during the day. This is a rich suburb so everyone is well-educated. The two dog-walkers whom I have met most recently are both attorneys who were at least moderately successful in the working world but who now choose not to work. Both women appear to be in their late 40s and describe having working husbands. One cheerfully said “My son is now in third grade so he doesn’t need me anymore,” and went on to explain that she volunteers on a library board and is writing a mystery novel (more for personal satisfaction than with any hope of earning money via publication). With their law degrees and employment experience, either woman could easily find a better-than-average job (maybe being a junior lawyer in a big firm isn’t a better-than-average job but plenty of companies, non-profits, and government agencies hire attorneys as well).
I tried a quick Google search and couldn’t find any psychology studies on whether having a job makes a person happier or not. These women, along with a lot of other Americans, are making presumably well-informed decisions that it wouldn’t make them happier to have a job, even one that they could do from home.
[Note that it is just coincidence that the two highly qualified non-workers whom I met happen to be women. I also know of plenty of “working-age”men who aren’t either working or performing hands-on child care. Some made money in an earlier phase of life. Several sued their high-earning wives under Massachusetts family law and are now living off the proceeds of those lawsuits (while having sex with younger women). Some are married to high-earning women.]
Readers: What do we think? Were the Calvinists right or the Ancient Greeks? If working is so great, why do people who are well-qualified and who know from personal experience what it is like to work choose not to work?
Full post, including comments