Good international bond fund for long-term investing?
I spoke with a certified financial planner at Vanguard last week. For security in the event of a U.S. stock market meltdown, he recommended holding some bonds via a fund. Which fund? One that invests exclusively in U.S. municipal bonds. That’s right, the folks that have signed up for pension and retiree health care obligations that they can’t even understand, much less pay (the shortfall is supposedly around $3 trillion, but since nobody knows how long people will live or how much health care will cost in the future, it could be much more). Also, in many cases, these are the bonds of sovereign entities that can default without leaving investors any recourse in federal courts (see this Brookings Institution article). Finally, given enough inflation in the U.S., these bonds would be paid back in “mini-dollars”.
The idea of California bonds as a hedge against the risk of a collapse in the price of Intel strikes me as a poor one. Would an investor be better off with a mixture of bonds from different economies worldwide and in different currencies? I’d feel a lot more comfortable holding bonds from Germany than from the city of Chicago. If the U.S. government’s money printing operation generates out of control inflation, it would be much nicer to be paid in Australian dollars (now worth more than the U.S. dollar, for the first time since 1983, when the currency began to trade freely) than in U.S. mini-dollars. And if the world muddles through more or less unchanged… the currency variations should average out to null and the interest rates on those foreign bonds should also be about the same as on dollar bonds.
One potential disadvantage to this plan is that foreign bonds don’t get the tax exemption on interest that U.S. municipal bonds get. Perhaps the sophisticated investor would buy the municipal bonds and insure them against default (and hope that, in the next crisis, whoever succeeds AIG as the biggest bond insurer also gets bailed out with money from the suckers (i.e., taxpayers)).
Another disadvantage seems to be high fees, in the neighborhood of 0.5% per year. The yield on a 10-year German bond is 3.14% (Pi, as far as a computer scientist is concerned), so fully 1/6th of the return goes to a manager. The expense ratio on a typical Vanguard bond fund is around 0.12%.
Does anyone have specific funds to recommend? Or perhaps a strategy of simply buying individual long-term bonds and holding them? (I have to believe that the trading fees for an individual buying a foreign bond are going to be much higher than what a fund would pay.)
Full post, including comments