Good home server for Windows network?
Folks: I have two PCs at home that are both fairly new and running Windows 7. They connect (sometimes) to several shared directories on an HP Mediasmart server. At times the shared directories can be browsed as though they were local; at other, unpredictable, times, an application will hang for 5-10 seconds waiting to get a directory listing. The HP Mediasmart, which is running Windows Home Server, seems to be one of the crummiest IT products ever designed. It can take a minute or two to log in to the admin console (when the computer and server are four feet apart and connected via gigabit Ethernet). Instead of using a standard operating system RAID1 arrangement, the Mediasmart duplicates information from disk to disk on a per-folder basis. When you copy a few GB of new data onto the server, the performance becomes even flakier for a day or so. The only thing that I can say in favor of the Mediasmart is that it has a good backup and restore service.
I didn’t like my previous NAS box, a ReadyNAS (now Linksys), because the admin console (viewed from a Web browser) was very slow to load, but the underlying SMB service was much better (I am pretty sure that it was running Linux and SAMBA), and the mechanical/fan noise from the box was too loud for domestic use.
What are my options? I have a hard time believing that this is the best that Windows can do with a shared drive, since I know that corporate slaves all over the U.S. are working off networked drives all day every day.
Full post, including comments