California’s billionaire tax will make California’s high-speed rail dream come true?

California proposes to confiscate roughly 5 percent of California billionaires’ wealth (Prop. 40 in the November election). Let’s ignore the fact that the first $1 billion in net worth is exempt and assume that California can harvest 5% of all billionaire wealth. Would that be sufficient to pay for a single high-speed rail line at California government project rates?

ChatGPT says the combined wealth of all of the billionaire douches (about 260 of them) in California is approximately $2.4 trillion, so a very rough estimate of the tax harvest is $120 billion. In fact, advocates of Prop. 40 say that they’ll get $100 billion. Here’s the neutral language of what voters are fed by nonpartisan election officials: “It will raise about $100 billion to replace the funding Trump and his billionaire donors took from working people to line their pockets.” This assumes that nobody moves out of Paradise to Hell (California to tax-free New Hampshire, Tennessee, Miami/Palm Beach, Austin, etc.), which, in any case wouldn’t reduce revenues from this new wealth tax (“The measure would apply the tax to billionaires who were California residents on January 1, 2026“).

Assuming that the advocates are correct and everything works as advertised, how many awesome high-speed rail lines could be built for $100 billion? The projected cost of the 30-year-old single line high-speed rail project is now up to $230 billion (Deplorables at Fox).

Imagine being the richest state in the U.S., imposing an entirely new kind of tax on the richest residents of that state, and still not having enough money to build the kind of railroad that folks in Japan, China, Europe, and Morocco are able to afford and build!

(I’m personally a fan of Prop. 40. California’s billionaires sat still for the 13% state income tax. Moving out of California won’t enable a rich douche to escape the 5% wealth haircut. Maybe a handful of people with assets between $25 million and $1 billion will move out for fear that the next election will hit the “almost rich” with a 5-10% wealth tax, but 23-year-old AI billionaires will quickly replace them. Californians are absurdly undertaxed, despite headlines and appearances. The owners of commercial property may pay almost nothing in property tax due to a combination of Prop. 13 and inflation (they pay tax on the nominal value of the property at the time of purchase plus 2% per year). There is no state estate tax, which makes California a good place for passing down the “generational wealth” that Californians say shouldn’t be possible to pass down. You’d think the peasants would revolt and say that Prop. 13 doesn’t apply to properties worth more than $2 million and that California will take 16% (the Maskachusetts/New York rate) of estates worth over $2 million. But for some reason these obvious methods of reducing inequality are never highlighted or put on the ballot.)

Irrelevant, in my view… “The Net Present Value of the California Billionaire Tax Act” (NBER) says that the tax will actually reduce net tax revenue for the state by about $39 billion over 10 years. The economists behind the paper claim that the billionaire targets of the tax will move out and, therefore, stop paying California’s 13.3% state income tax. Why is that irrelevant? $4 billion/year is only about 1% per year of the state government’s colossal spending. Californians say that they hate inequality and, therefore, they should be happy to bear 1% more of the cost of running their government in exchange for getting rid of some of their richest douches. I would feel more pride of ownership in our 2021 Honda Odyssey if we could expel from the neighborhood the guy with the new Rolls-Royce and also the guy with the 2005 Ford GT. And maybe the other guy with the Rolls-Royce who has been observed (by our 5th grader) picking up in the car line at the local public elementary school. Would that be worth paying more in tax? Sure. If my envy level were high enough, it could even be worth paying 10% more in taxes (property and sales here in Florida; we have no income or estate tax).

Full post, including comments

The long tail of losing tax base via lockdown (and of gaining tax base by rejecting Faucism)

A woman around age 30 who works for Cleveland Clinic here (yes, I know that it sounds like a contradiction, but Cleveland Clinic has a massive operation in SE Florida) shared her Floridian Origin Story. She and her now-husband came to Fort Lauderdale on vacation in 2020 and discovered that it was possible for young people to enjoy a mask-free lockdown-free lifestyle without being felled by SARS-CoV-2. The couple packed up and moved and never looked back to their deep roots in Massachusetts (the now-wife had grown up in a house that her grandparents purchased and her parents still live there).

How much tax base was lost via the transformation from Massachusetts to Maskachusetts? The immediately loss was modest, only about 5 percent of perhaps $250,000 in joint income or $12,500 per year in state income tax. Figure another $2,000 in lost sales tax and $5,000 per year in lost property tax (whether the couple had rented or purchased). A total of $20,000 per year.

What’s the long tail? The parents are executives back in MA and they’re approaching retirement age. They are planning to keep their house on Cape Cod, but live in Florida for most of the year so that they can spend time with their daughter and any grandkids. If the daughter hadn’t been driven to Florida by the lockdowns, mask orders, vaccine orders, etc., the parents wouldn’t have followed. The state will likely lose at least another $40,000 per year in tax receipts and won’t get the state estate tax that they’d hoped to harvest from the dead bodies of the parents. (See Effect on children’s wealth when parents move to Florida.)

Although Florida lacks both income and estate taxes, these folks are contributing to the Florida economy and tax base by living here. Thus, it seems that Ron DeSantis’s decision to reject Faucism and follow the Church of Sweden will pay financial dividends to the state for many decades to come.

Loosely related, sunset approaches at Pine Glades Natural Area, about 20 minutes from Abacoa.

Full post, including comments

Floridians and Texans should never buy a second home in a state with income and/or estate taxes

I hope that everyone’s National Estate Planning Awareness Month is going well. As the nation’s successful make their way down to Florida for “the season”, a cautionary tale from the Wall Street Journal: “Was His Home Connecticut or Florida? The Difference Is a $13 Million Tax Bill”.

A rich douche spent 5.5 months in Connecticut during his last year on this planet and that generate a huge amount of litigation over whether CT can harvest estate tax (reducing the kids’ inheritance). He could have avoided all of the drama for his executor simply by making his northern home anywhere away from the states of color in the Tax Foundation map below.

The Islamic Republic of Michigan, for example, or Live Free and Die Free in New Hampshire. Even California would have been a far better choice since elites there refuse to live their own principles by imposing an estate tax to reduce income inequality and the “generational wealth” that they decry.

A bit part of the mess seems to be that, like Marjorie Merriweather Post, the builder of Mar-a-Lago, this douche had three regular residences: FL, AZ, and CT. So he wasn’t anchored in Florida for 183 days per year.

It is all increasingly complicated when people can work anywhere and have multiple homes. The fights between states and the wealthy are playing out in an increasing number of residency audits, said Timothy Noonan, a lawyer who leads a tax residency practice at Hodgson Russ in New York City.

The trial court judge homed in on one factor: Anderson typically spent 5½ months a year from May to mid-October in Greenwich, and 3½ months from November through mid-February in Florida. He spent three months from mid-February through early May in Arizona.

The judge concluded that “ultimately, the most persuasive evidence demonstrating Anderson’s domicile is where he chose to spend his most valuable and limited resource: his time.”

The trial court concluded that Anderson’s personal, social and property connections with Connecticut and Florida were generally equal, but that the estate failed to prove by clear and convincing evidence that Connecticut wasn’t his true home.

Here’s the Vero Beach place:

Estate tax is particularly hazardous. My late mother’s college friend was a passionate Democrat who avoided paying any tax to the Democrats of Maskachusetts by spending 183 days per year in her Palm Beach place. I hope that she lives forever, but what if in the last year of her life she falls ill while on a January visit to MA and then ends up staying through December in MA for continuity of medical care? MA wouldn’t have a slam-dunk case to collect estate tax, but they could certainly argue that the deceased had given up FL residence and it was time to collect 16% ahead of the kids, the ACLU, Planned Parenthood, and other beneficiaries.

Here’s an Ohio-based law firm’s web page on National Estate Planning Awareness Month showing a typical high-net-worth Ohio family (and no other client photos):

Google AI: “The median household income for Black or African American households in Ohio is approximately $42,433 to $45,800 per year, according to recent state demographic snapshots and census data. This is lower than the overall state median household income, which sits above $71,000”,

Grok: “Law firm marketing frequently uses multi-racial or Black family stock images for inclusivity branding, aspirational messaging, or to signal that services are open to everyone. It is not an attempt to accurately depict the statistical modal client. This is common across many professional-service websites and does not change the underlying demographics of who actually pays for attorney-drafted plans. In short: the image is marketing aesthetics. The typical paying customer for this service in Ohio remains a higher-wealth, usually White household.”

ChatGPT characterizes the image as “generic stock-photo family”, implying that it was chosen at random. Pressed, the AI admits that the law firm’s likely clients are rich white people. How does the image help market to those douches? “It could help if the firm thinks affluent white clients care about signals beyond “this family looks like me.” Marketing often tries to communicate things such as “modern,” “inclusive,” “welcoming,” or “serves the whole community.” Some wealthy white prospective clients may respond positively to that branding.”

Also from the Wall Street Journal, a couple in Manhattan whose kids’ inheritance will be reduced if they don’t move…

“Kids?” you might ask if you remember anything from your high school biology class.

Martin, 60, and his husband, Andrew Farach-Colton, 63, were living in that tiny Upper West Side apartment in 1999 when they found out they would be the fathers of twins. They wanted more space, but knew they couldn’t get it in Manhattan on their salaries.

Full post, including comments

Why not fight inequality in corporate profitability?

I hope that everyone is getting ready for International Equal Pay Day, coming up on the 18th. Americans fight (thank God!) inequality in individual earnings with the world’s most progressive tax system. Why not also fight inequality at the corporate level?

Nvidia’s recent quarterly report:

(The company is so forward-thinking that they’re already in 2027 while us peasants are stuck in 2026.)

Net income was almost $60 billion and an even-more-eye-popping 62% of revenue. For every dollar in sales, the company enjoys 62 cents in profit. The typical S&P 500 company earns about 15% in what the NYT tells us is an economy that has been destroyed by Donald Trump (the 10-year average is 11%).

(I want to pause here and take credit for my investment acumen. My standard line was that Nvidia’s profit margin couldn’t stay at 30%, despite the goodness of CUDA, because people who were big users of GPU would find better price/performance chips and recompile their software to run on those competitor GPUs. These latest quarterly results certainly prove my prediction correct because the profit margin did not stay at 30% (it moved to 62%). “Follow me for more investment advice.”)

Federal corporate income tax isn’t based on profitability, but is a flat 21% (Nvidia actually pays closer to 16.5% due to some money being earned in countries with lower tax rates, credits for research, etc.).

Bernie Sanders informs us that nobody needs to own more than 3 houses. The analogy for a corporation would be that no company needs to earn more than a 25% profit margin and, therefore, the corporate income tax rate should go up closer to 100% on the chunk of a company’s earnings that are more than 25%.

Speaking of Bernie and Nvidia, TIME’s 100 AI “innovators, leaders, and thinkers reshaping our world through groundbreaking advances in artificial intelligence” does not include any current or former employees of Nvidia (sorry, Jensen Huang, Bill Dally, and the rest of the merry band identified in Even companies worth $1 trillion don’t want to pay Nvidia’s prices). Bernie Sanders, however, is featured as one of the top 100:

Perhaps this is because Senator Sanders was the first author of the 2017 paper that kicked off the modern LLM:

Full post, including comments

Avoiding the Mamdani Caliphate’s pied-à-terre tax with a child in college

A friend in Wall Street, but not quite on Wall Street told me about a potential way around Ayatollah Mamdani’s pied-à-terre tax. The typical rich douche who is rich enough to have a NYC place as his or her 3rd home is also rich enough to have reproduced successfully (unlike the American working class; see below for how they’re being bred out of existence). If the douche owner has a child in college or grad/professional school, the child can declare the fancy apartment as his/her/zir/their primary residence so long as he/she/ze/they comes “home” during breaks. At that point, no tax is owed because an immediate family member is living in the place. The law says “For purposes of this article, the phrase “immediate family member” means a spouse, child, sibling, parent, grandparent, or grandchild.”

Separately, a recent photo from Manhattan that includes a mixture of haram and halal outfits for females:

(ChatGPT says that American Muslims wouldn’t vote to outlaw these shameless un-Islamic displays of female flesh because “The evidence from actual Muslim political organizations in the U.S. points much more toward protecting Muslims’ own religious practices than toward imposing Islamic dress rules on everyone else” and then admits “What American Muslim organizations advocate while Muslims are a small minority tells us something about their current priorities, but it does not reliably tell us what the same constituency would advocate if it controlled legislatures. … I would expect some political pressure around the margins. It might take forms such as stricter school dress codes, sex-segregated recreation, modest uniforms, objections to sexually explicit advertising, accommodation of gender segregation, or pressure on municipal facilities.” ChatGPT cited a Pew survey in which a majority of Muslim women said that they themselves wear hijab in public.)

Incidentally, the sourdough bagels (Apollo Bagels) for which people were waiting in line (30+ minutes) didn’t seem as good as what we get in the local strip mall from Bagel Boyz. I’m sure that they were made perfectly, but not sure that sourdough is the answer for bagels. Measured by traditional criteria, a Dunkin bagel might actually be better than the best sourdough bagel! (Did I wait in line behind the haram blonde? No! This was place was right next to my hotel so I popped in at 2 pm when there was no line.)

Full post, including comments

Maskachusetts starts work on an exit tax

It’s Juneteenth and Black Americans are celebrating the end of slavery.

(Except, of course, for the millions of Black Americans who are immigrants and who have no relationship to the roughly 400,000 African slaves who were imported to British North America/the U.S. And also not Black Americans in service jobs who have to work today while whites who work for the government, nonprofits (also government!), and Big Tech are relaxing with pay.)

A friend is also celebrating freedom this week because he finally unloaded his old house in Maskachusetts. He moved to Florida a year ago, but the market for high-end houses in MA is slow and he had some work to do on the place. It might have been inadvertently smart to sell the house in a tax year after he was completely gone. The new Massachusetts Millionaire’s Tax applies only to MA-source income. So he will owe tax only on the capital gain in 2026 and that should be under $1 million after the $500,000 exclusion for a married couple. Note that the “gain” is entirely fictitious and disappears once you adjust his purchase price for 19 years of official CPI. It would actually be a significant loss in real terms if adjusted for CPI as previously calculated, i.e., before the “owners’ equivalent rent” scam (see also “Summers: Inflation Reached 18% In 2022 Using The Government’s Previous Formula” (Forbes)). If he’d sold in the year that he moved, the rest of his income would have pushed the total well over $1 million and he’d be paying tax (on a loss in real dollars!) at the 9% rate rather than 5%.

Is my friend free, free at last from Maskachusetts state taxes? Not quite. Selling real estate is considered “Massachusetts source income” and, therefore, MA state income tax is owed. So many rich people are bailing out on paying for whatever Gov. Maura Healey and Boston Mayor Michelle Wu have dreamed up that the state is fearful it won’t get its pound of flesh from those who’d fled. There is a new law that requires the withholding of likely capital gains tax at the time of the sale. It applies only if the seller is a nonresident, i.e., has moved to tax-free New Hampshire or tax-free Florida.

Starting November 1, 2025, a withholding agent is required to file a Form NRW for every real estate transaction when the gross sales price is $1,000,000 or more. If the seller (aka, Transferor) is a nonresident or a business with no continuing Massachusetts presence, the withholding agent may also be required to withhold tax.

The withholding rules on sales or exchanges of real estate generally require a withholding agent to withhold an amount reasonably equivalent to the personal income tax or corporate excise, as applicable, that will be due on the net gain from a non-resident’s sale or exchange of Massachusetts real property. Non-resident sellers (or other transferors of property) include individuals and business corporations with no continuing Massachusetts business presence.

(The new regulation drives up costs to both buyers and sellers, incidentally. The lawyers on both sides now have to be paid to review the forms relating to this new law (grew from 2 pages in 2025 to 3 pages in 2026). A lawyer on one side has to be paid about $300 to file the form with the DOR.)

I wonder if this could be the foot in the door for a more general state exit tax, e.g., something like the federal exit tax on people who renounce U.S. citizenship. Someone fleeing NY, MA, or CA would have to pay tax on all unrealized capital gains at the time of the move to a different state.

Here’s a Harvard Journal on Legislation article, “NO MIGRATION WITHOUT TAXATION: STATE EXIT TAXES”:

The author starts from the proposition that it was living in, e.g., Massachusetts, that enabled a person to make money. Only because the taxpayer lived in Boston was he/she/ze/they able to buy stock in ASML (Dutch) and Novo Nordisk (Danish) and, therefore, he/she/ze/they should have to pay capital gains tax on these stocks before fleeing to Florida.

If a taxing jurisdiction provides benefits to a taxpayer that allow the taxpayer to generate income, that jurisdiction should have the ability to impose tax on the resulting income … The problem arises with taxpayer mobility. If a taxing jurisdiction has a strict realization requirement, all the income that accrued within that jurisdiction could migrate to another jurisdiction along with the taxpayer before the realization event occurs. The taxing jurisdiction that provided the benefits that facilitated the income would lose the ability to tax it. The resulting tax revenue would inure to a different taxing jurisdiction that did not deserve it, or more commonly, would be eliminated through simple tax planning strategies.

The benefit theory’s fundamental premise is that individuals generate their income and wealth because the government provides economic, physical, and legal infrastructure; protection of property; and other facets of an “orderly, civilized society.”

(Obama’s “You didn’t build that”; why isn’t the fair tax rate 100% then?)

A state exit tax may not be entirely tax neutral, but it moves the overall tax regime toward neutrality. A state’s existing personal income tax regime without an exit tax creates a strong incentive to migrate out of the state before realizing income or gain, as discussed in Section IV.B. Imposing a tax on the gain that accrued while the taxpayer resided in the state removes that tax incentive to migrating out of the state, thus making the migration decision more tax neutral. With an exit tax that deems an exit to constitute a realization event, the detriment to migration is essentially just one of timing. The taxpayer can stay in the state and pay tax when there is a true realization event or leave the state and pay tax now. As discussed above, however, this assertion relies on an unavoidable realization event if the taxpayer remains in the state.

(This would certainly discourage people from moving. If they stay in a high-tax state they can avoid paying tax on unrealized capital gains for decades or perhaps forever (steps up at death). If they migrate, on the other hand, they must immediately pay tax on unrealized gains.)

The article seems to have been written in 2021, i.e., before the Mamdani Caliphate was established. However, the author has some specific guidance for how Ayatollah Mamdani could get cash from those who flee only as far as the Hamptons or Westchester County:

Although this Article’s focus is state exit taxes, there are localities that could similarly benefit from an exit tax regime. Interstate migration is quite easy, while intrastate migration is even easier, which leaves many localities such as New York City, San Francisco, and Seattle particularly vulnerable. The options are fewer for localities, even those with the power to impose an income tax, and many localities’ best option is piggybacking on a state exit tax. Localities could attempt to impose their own freestanding exit taxes, or creative exit tax alternatives that impose property tax or some other tax and grant credits in future years for the additional tax paid only if the taxpayer still resides in the state. These standalone options, however, are difficult to administer and susceptible to challenge.

The glorious conclusion:

States cannot prevent people from moving, but states can prevent the tax base from moving with them.

Where is the law professor who wants to save Maskachusetts, California, and New York while starving Florida of its daily fresh supply of rich people? Is he/she/ze/they in Cambridge, along with the journal’s publisher? In Brooklyn, perhaps? Maybe in San Francisco at Kamala Harris’s old law school? Remarkably, at the time he wrote the article, Professor Andrew Appleby was a professor at Stetson University College of Law, which is in Gulfport, Florida (Tampa metro area). He’s now moved to University of Tennessee, i.e., to another tax-free state that prospers when rich-but-mismanaged states in the Northeast raise tax rates. So.. the taxpayers of Tennessee are paying this guy to promote the idea that New York should impose a crippling tax on anyone who is thinking of moving to Tennessee and start paying property and sales taxes in TN.

Separately, consider that the modern economy has a winner-take-all aspect for companies (Apple and NVIDIA,), individuals (Jeff Bezos and any woman who manages to get him into Family Court), and geographical areas (Silicon Valley, San Francisco’s Cerebral Valley (the LLM companies), and NYC for finance). If the geographical areas that have won 90% of the income are able to prevent people from moving away via exit taxation then the places that currently get a few scraps won’t get anything at all. Although politicians and residents of the “winner places” love to talk about their passion for reducing inequality, I have a feeling that they’ll try to scoop up that last 10% with an exit tax, just as the Tennessee-taxpayer-supported professor suggests.

Loosely related, anyone who can afford $1,000/day for hotels, food, etc. could have visited our national parks today for free in 2025 (sign in our Olympic National Park hotel; of course, the promised daily housekeeping never occurred!):

Not so in 2026 because the Hater in Chief substituted Flag Day and Independence Day weekend for MLK, Jr. Day and Juneteenth.

Full post, including comments

Ron DeSantis wants to set up Florida property taxes to be like federal income taxes (paid by a minority and benefiting the majority)

Here’s a disturbing proposal from a politician whose policies I generally agree with:

While I don’t enjoy paying property tax, the idea that the majority of Floridians eligible to vote will soon pay nothing seems like a recipe for much faster growth in county/local government spending. (Many Florida voters already pay next to nothing because they’re taxed on the original purchase price and perhaps that is what accounts for the rapid rise in county spending that Gov. DeSantis decries.)

If the majority of Floridians aren’t paying property tax, won’t they vote for every blue sky spending dream that counties and cities put forward? That’s how it works at the federal level. The majority pay either nothing or next to nothing and have voted the U.S. into the world’s largest or second largest welfare state, as a percentage of GDP (we vie with France for the title). Even if a homeowner who isn’t taxed receives only 1 penny of benefit for every additional $1 million spent it would still be rational for him or her to vote for increased spending.

Is there a method to Ron DeSantis’s apparent madness? I’m sure that he understands politics much better than I do, but I am struggling to find merit in narrowing the tax base and feel that the experiment has already been run on the American people. If the goal is limiting county spending, why not a state-imposed limit on county/local government spending? Take the 75th percentile of per-capita spending in 2025 and impose that as a limit, adjusted annually for inflation, on all Florida counties. A county that is already over the limit would have five years to come down into alignment with the law. This might force counties to eliminate affordable housing subsidies, for example, which have the potential to be infinitely expensive as well as certainly unequal (some people get below-market-rate housing; others, equally virtuous and equally situated, are forced to pay market rates).

Maybe the method in the apparent madness is that homesteaded property isn’t that important to county budgets, e.g., for Miami-Dade just 7 percent of the total budget. ChatGPT says it is 9 percent of the total Palm Beach County budget. Both of these counties have a lot of commercial real estate, but property tax as a whole isn’t the lion’s share of the budget as I would have expected.

Republicans in general seem to be competing with Democrats in the “make the rich pay for everything” department. As noted above, I don’t see how this can work in a democracy where the people paying nothing have the right to vote for unlimited enhancements to whatever they’re receiving from a government funded by a minority that can be trivially out-voted. Maybe it can work in California and New York City where AI and Wall Street actually do generate infinite wealth on a recurring basis, but Florida isn’t home to NVIDIA and the AI companies that use NVIDIA chips.

Full post, including comments

New York’s pied-à-terre tax vs. Florida’s homestead discount

New York City (and maybe the state as well) are generating outrage by proposing to tax residential real estate that isn’t a primary residence at a higher rate than the same property would pay if occupied by somewho who was a full-time NYC resident.

What other city or state indulges in this outrageous abuse of society’s successful? Florida! Let’s look at starter homes in Palm Beach. Here’s one that was purchased for $4.45 million in 2011 and is today worth $14.3 million (Zillow).

The tax assessment is still less than the purchase price, presumably due to the fact that the assessed value for a “homestead” (primary residence) can’t go up more than 3 percent or the increase in CPI, whichever is lower:

If there were an identical house next door and it sold for $14 million to someone who used it only 4 months per year, the town/county could collect property tax on the full value, i.e., 3X the tax rate paid by the primary resident.

A surcharge for part-time residents generates outrage. A discount for full-time residents doesn’t upset anyone. NYC could have doubled property tax rates, with state permission, and then offered a steep discount for anyone who pays resident NYC income tax.

Full post, including comments

Suspend the exit tax to get rid of Elon Musk and other toxic billionaires?

From the Harvard Book Store, a window into the thinking of our nation’s cognitive elite:

The #2 hardcover bestseller during my April 2025 visit was Muskism:

Elon Musk isn’t a glitch in the system—he is the system. His worldview promises sovereignty through technology: plug in, power up, and become self-reliant. But the more you connect, the more he owns you.

If Fordism defined the capitalism of the twentieth century, Muskism may define the twenty-first. Fordism helped build the welfare state. Musk undoes it. He thrives on dependence while preaching freedom. His cars run on subsidies; his satellites run the battlefield; his social networks train the AI that trains us.

Muskism sells itself as the future but entrenches age-old hierarchies. It offers autonomy for some and exclusion for others. It’s pro-natalist but anti-immigrant, futurist but reactionary. It speaks of humanity but warns against empathy.

The authors:

Quinn Slobodian is professor of international history at Boston University

Ben Tarnoff is a writer and technologist based in Massachusetts … He is a frequent contributor to the New York Review of Books, and has also written for the New York Times, The New Yorker, and the New Republic,

These giant credentialed academically-inclined brains say that Elon is pernicious. He’s our “dependent”, which means he is costing us money. What’s worse, this spending has resulted in Musk “owning us” rather than vice versa.

Elon Musk is pernicious and we’d certainly be better off without him. But it is also bad to be “anti-immigrant”, according to the authors, and we thus can’t use our ICE thugs to denaturalize Musk and deport him. Maybe we could persuade him to leave voluntarily? Hardly likely, given the U.S.’s massive exit tax on those who renounce U.S. citizenship. Elon would have to pay 20% capital gains tax plus 3.8% Obamacare tax (NIIT), albeit not the 13.3% California state income tax since he moved to Texas rather than pay his fair share to Gavin Newsom. This tax rate would be assessed against substantially all of Musk’s assets since nearly all of his wealth is unrealized capital gains.

What if we offered our most toxic citizens, the ones who contribute the least to our prosperity (since they don’t pay their fair share of taxes) and contribute the most to our problems (all of the above-cited, plus their presence in our society exacerbates inequality), a reasonable cost way out? If they leave in 2026, for example, they wouldn’t have to pay the exit tax.

Let’s say that someone needs a minimum net worth of $200 million to make the rest of us truly sick with envy. Anyone under $200 million, therefore, would still have to pay for expatriation.

(Separately, one of our neighbors has taken to parking his or her fairly new Rolls-Royce on the street (to make room for a truly valuable car in the garage?). I often walk Mindy the Crippler (our golden retriever) with a physician across the street and his dogs. In response to the Rolls-Royce sighting, the doctor and I have agreed that anyone richer than us should have to pay a 100% wealth tax.)

(Department of Trust Official Sources: SpaceX has a 98% launch success rate over its corporate life. The authors and HarperCollins (publisher) have chosen to feature on the cover a photo of one of the 2% unsuccessful launches.)

Full post, including comments

Statistics on taxes paid by the undocumented

Happy Tax Week for those dumb enough to work and pay federal personal income tax (about half of us, as Mitt Romney famously noted)…

I hope that all of you put extra postage on your tax payments this year since the money needs to go all the way to Somalia and Diego Garcia. Maybe with enough undocumented low-skill migrants our economy will be so rich that none of the native-born will have to pay taxes? There are some statistics hidden in “To File or Not to File: Undocumented Immigrants Face a Tax Return Dilemma” (New York Times):

The federal treasury could take a hit. Many undocumented immigrants have taxes withheld in every paycheck, but experts worry some could shift into under-the-table jobs. Others with less formal earnings may now skip filing a tax return — and therefore not pay federal taxes at all. The Yale Budget Lab, a nonpartisan research center, projected lost tax revenue of about $300 billion over a decade.

Yale estimated that we were being enriched by 22 million undocumented migrants in 2016, which would mean a population of approximately 30 million enrichers today without legal immigration status. If we divide $300 billion by 30 million and then by 10 years we get $1,000/year paid by each enricher into a welfare state where each dependent family costs nearly $100,000 per year (some data in pre-Biden dollars). A different study in the same article works out to about $2,000/year paid per undocumented migrant:

Before the agreement between the I.R.S. and ICE, unauthorized immigrants paid roughly $60 billion annually in federal taxes, according to an estimate by the Institute on Taxation and Economic Policy, a progressive think tank. Much of it went to Social Security and Medicare, which are programs that undocumented immigrants cannot benefit from.

(I think the last sentence is factually incorrect, despite the NYT’s claims of checking facts. As soon as an undocumented immigrant’s anchor baby turns 21, the undocumented migrant is immediately eligible for a green card and, thus, immediately eligible to receive Social Security and Medicare.)

The New York Times repeats the absurd statistic that the number of undocumented migrants in the U.S. has barely grown over the past 30 years, even during the Biden-Harris administration’s open border period (see the Yale study: “There’s a number that everybody quotes”):

About 14 million undocumented immigrants lived in the United States in 2023, the latest available estimate, and about 70 percent of them were in the labor force, according to the Pew Research Center, a nonpartisan think tank.

Department of Undocumented Migrants Aren’t Getting Welfare:

But last year’s Republican tax law cut off the child tax credit, which had been available to families if a child was a U.S. citizen.

(A cash handout from federal taxpayers (“the chumps”) isn’t “welfare”, apparently.)

The child tax credit by itself is $2,200, $1,700 of which is “refundable” (i.e., if you don’t owe any tax because you don’t work or have a low income then you get $1,700 anyway). So the child tax credit alone is larger than even the largest estimate of taxes paid per undocumented migrant.

Full post, including comments